I Tried 5 Top-Rated Mascaras & Here’s How They Break Down

June 14, 2018

I was in Ulta the other day picking up a few things and naturally browsing mascaras (as I always am). The sales assistant on the floor came over to ask if she could help me find anything, which got us into talking and laughing about the never ending search for the perfect mascara.

Guys....it doesn't exist! I mean but really, how terribly hard can it be to invent a product that lengthens, volumizes, separates, stays on and actually keeps doing what it's supposed to do until it's time to buy the next tube?!

So the answer is and will always be no, I haven't yet found the perfect mascara. BUT I have tried quite a few lately (some that I do really like). Here's how 5 of the top-rated mascaras break down in my book.



 

so desperately wanted to love Benefit's Better Than Sex mascara. It's ridiculously close to being the perfect combination of everything I was looking for in a mascara, but it falls short in one major category: flakiness.

I put this mascara on in the morning, half of it is IN my eyes by 10am, and the rest is under my eyes by noon. I don't use waterproof mascaras because I don't have 10 minutes every night to remove my mascara, so I really can't speak to the waterproof versions of ANY of these. That being said, a non-waterproof mascara should be able to hold its own...don't you think?! It has so, so much potential because the separation, volumizing and lengthening are all on point, but the flakiness is a killer for me. You can't love a mascara that doesn't last, so I'm giving this one a 7.2.

What I like:
+ Separates (which I personally think is super hard to find!)
+ Volumizes
+ Lengthens
+ Nice dense black color

What I don't:
+ Flakes
+ Smudges

 

top 5 mascaras
top 5 mascaras

 

Diorshow was a total, on-a-whim purchase while standing at the Sephora checkout line. The girls standing in line next to me were talking it up, the salesperson said it was great (or so she heard), and so I was like, why not?

I'll tell you why not: because it sucks. Over the years I've found that I prefer the thick, bristled brushes (which Diorshow has) and so I thought that, combined with a few great reviews would make it worth its while. Not the case with this one.

Diorshow lacks majorly in the volume department, and I felt like I would've needed 3+ coats to be halfway satisfied. Additionally, it gave my lashes a stiff, almost 'crunchy' texture, which should never happen with a good mascara. Lastly, this is another one that just doesn't stay on...I had smudges under my eyes by midday.

What I like:
+ Nice dense black color

What I don't:
+ Lacking volume
+ Clumps
+ Gives eyelashes a stiff texture
+ Smudges
+ Overall a high-end product that just doesn't deliver

 

 

I actually first tried out Lancôme's Monsieur Big thanks to you guys! After asking for your top mascara recommendations on Instagram Stories, this one got an overwhelming response as one of your favorites.

The qualities I love about this mascara are comparable to Better Than Sex. It has a super thick, bristled brush which helps to separate, volumize and lengthen (although a little more umph in the length department wouldn't hurt!). All in all, it's my favorite of the 5 in this post.

The only things I don't love are that it can be rather hard to get off, especially as a non-waterproof mascara (but I guess that's better than it coming off in hours like the others), and also that it dries out rather quickly. Ultimately, however, I plan to restock this and continue using until I find the next best thing!

What I like:
+ Separates
+ Volumizes
+ Lengthens

What I don't:
+ A bit hard to get off for a non-waterproof
+ Tube dries out quickly

 

top 5 mascaras
top 5 mascaras

 

I purchased Lancôme's Grandiose in conjunction with Mr. Big, since it was another that had pretty good reviews from you guys on Instagram. The first time I tried it, I didn't love it and thought that I would definitely be returning it. However when Mr. Big dried out after a few weeks and I was left with no mascara, I decided to give it another go.

The curved wand was a bit odd to get used to at first, but I actually ended up finding the shape really convenient after a few uses, making the application easier. I bumped its rating down a bit from Mr. Big however, because it doesn't quite live up to everything I look for in a mascara (although it does get the job done and I do like it).

I don't love the plastic bristles and much prefer natural, long ones. I tend to find that mascaras with plastic bristles are more likely to clump, which I do see with this mascara. I sometimes use a dry mascara brush to brush out my lashes after applying, to help separate them (which usually does the trick). As for the length and volume, it does a pretty good job. That being said though it's just not anything I'm super impressed with.

What I like:
+ Long-lasting
+ Volumizes
+ Lengthens

What I don't:
+ Tends to clump
+ A bit hard to get off for a non-waterproof
+ Doesn't lengthen and volumize enough

 

 

Bad Gal Lash is one of my OG mascaras. I used it all through college and recently decided to give it another try since it had been one I really loved. To my surprise though, I didn't love it as much as I did on the second go-around.

While I love the big, thick-bristled brush, I felt like it just didn't deliver like it used to. Like Grandiose, this is another mascara that's good enough and gets the job done, but it just isn't incredibly great.

Bad Gal Lash does do a great job of lengthening and is pretty good in the volume department. During the first few uses, it sometimes clumps though, so that dry mascara brush comes in handy. What I really didn't love is that with a few coats, it started to clump. The formula also seemed to dry out quicker than it should've.

What I like:
+ Lengthens
+ Volumizes
+ Curls

What I don't:
+ Tends to clump
+ Dries out quickly

 

top 5 mascaras

So that's the rundown, and yes, I'm still on the hunt for that perfect
mascara. Would love to hear your recs in the comments below!

Share:

25 responses to “I Tried 5 Top-Rated Mascaras & Here’s How They Break Down”

  1. Seems like you weren’t that excited about any of these… so much for top rated huh? That’s why I don’t tend to trust reviews… not including yours of course 😉

  2. Lindsay says:

    I’ve tried a few of the Lancôme ones and enjoyed them, but my favorite is definitely Lash paradise!

  3. sandy a la mode says:

    SUCH a good breakdown!! I love this! I need to try the Lancome one out!!

  4. Liz says:

    I use Monsiuer Big and it is hands down the best mascara I’ve used! My fave by far!

  5. Azanique says:

    I love the Lancome one! It’s great for lengthening for me but the tube tries so quick. I’m so glad I’m not the only one who noticed that!

    -xo, Azanique | http://www.lotsofsass.com

  6. Gabrielle says:

    As much as I am normally NOT a drugstore makeup fan, my big exception is L’Oreal’s Voluminous Superstar mascara. I love it to pieces. Definitely worth giving a try in my book.

  7. Cathy says:

    Great review!! My favorite is Dior, I am addicted!

    XOXO
    Cathy

  8. Greta says:

    I use It Cosmetics and have loved it for years! Definitely give it a try!

  9. Megan says:

    This is so helpful! I am always trying new mascara’s and now I know what to try next!
    Megan | http://www.pipmegan.com

  10. Brittany says:

    This is such an excellent post!! I feel the same about the BTS!! I wanted to love it, but mine runs all down my eyes and I look like a raccoon. I love the wand, tho! I need to try some of these other ones!

    Brittany,
    http://www.lawyerlookbook.com

  11. Lee says:

    This is SUCH a great review post – thank you so much for the inside scoop! Im still on the hunt for the perfect mascara as well. I found the EXACT same thing with the better than sex mascara (flakes and smudges) and was so surprised since so many blogger rave about it. I’m currently using a drug store find – the L’Oreal Double Extend and it’s the best I’ve found so far. You should check it out!
    Lee | LegalLee Blonde

  12. Lily says:

    It can be so hard to find the perfect mascara. I agree with your thoughts on the BTS mascara — it flakes so much!

  13. Shira says:

    I found the same with better than sex! Monsieur big was also pretty clumpy for me.

    https://asequinloveaffair.com

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *